Belfast-born doctor pushes ME research
Dara Gantly
Dara Gantly talks to
Dr Derek Enlander - a Belfast-born doctor
who specialises in the diagnosis and treatment of myalgic encepalomyelitis (ME) -
also known as chronic fatigue syndrome -
in his New York practice.
It was two decades ago, on a return visit to his native Belfast,
that Dr Derek Enlander formed what was to become a lasting interest
in myalgic encephalomyelitis (ME). Now often diagnosed under the
name Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (CFS), ME is a potentially disabling
and chronic illness, affecting the brain, muscles and immune system
that can cause profound exhaustion, pain and mental confusion.
Having graduated from the RCSI in 1963 and trained at the Meath Hospital,
Dr Enlander left for Stanford University in California in 1966 under a fellowship scheme,
initially for just one year, researching the Epstein-Barr virus.
He has lived and worked in the US ever since.
Childhood friend
During one of his return visits to Northern Ireland,
Dr Enlander was asked by a childhood friend to help him in the then little-known condition,
ME [Dr Melvin Ramsay at the Royal Free Hospital in London had written the seminal text on the condition in the mid-1950s],
which had caused his friend to curtail his successful estate agency business.
"My school friend in Belfast said to me
that when I went back to America,
I had to find out about this disease so that I could help him.
That formed my interest.
This was 18 to 19 years ago," recalled Dr Enlander.
His practice in New York is now devoted to ME/CFS and fibromyalgia,
and he is a recognised expert in the field across the globe.
Dr Enlander has not quite lost his Belfast accent,
and continues his professional relationship with Ireland in a number of ways.
In fact,
he has been chosen as the Irish representative on a new European Think Tank for ME,
which held its first meeting last weekend (June 13) in Norway.
Set up by a new organisation called the European Society for ME,
the Think Tank wants to promote cooperation among scientists to stimulate new research.
The 10-member group wants
to initiate an effective research effort
to find the secret behind the somewhat mysterious disease.
Doctors and scientists are still confused over what causes ME,
which is estimated to affect around 12,000 people in Ireland.
While the exact cause remains unknown,
most patients experience a flu-like illness before onset.
Uncertainty
This uncertainty has only added to the controversy surround ME, as
patients often look well and have normal bloods returned when tested.
"The doctor is [often] skeptical and
believes the patient must be imagining that they are sick.
The idea that they can't work is
because they are lazy or they are neurotic,
and they are given this label of a psychiatric neurosis,"
explained Dr Enlander.
"But this is not a psychiatric disease.
This is a physical disease," he stressed.
"It has been shown that there is a dysfunction of the immune system,
and it is this dysfunction that people are now actually focusing on for treatment."
Dr Enlander is highly critical of psychiatrists
who believe graded exercise therapy and cognitive therapy can be effective treatment.
"We have found that
graded exercise therapy can actually be detrimental to the patient's progress;
it can actually produce relapse.
Yet this is proclaimed by several psychiatric experts to be the only mode of treatment," he told IMT.
"This is very, very damaging.
The idea of labelling these patients as 'psychiatric' is very problematic,
because it produces greater stress, and stress produces relapse."
ME has been around for centuries,
and it is thought both Florence Nightingale and Charles Darwin suffered from it,
after they returned from the Crimea and Galapagos respectively.
Neurasthenia
It has had many names,
including neurasthenia (1800s), post-viral fatigue syndrome (PVFS), and Royal Free Disease
- a major outbreak occurred in London's Royal Free Hospital in 1955.
ME used to occur in mini-epidemics, but since 1956 it is more usually seen in isolated cases.
A newer name is Chronic Fatigue Syndrome.
However, it only describes fatigue and
CFS can be confused with chronic tiredness, "burn-out" and depression.
While Dr Enlander prefers the term ME,
he believes there is really no ideal term for the disease.
"You can poke holes into any term.
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome unfortunately was coined in America and the term creates great skepticism.
Doctors don't understand the disease.
Then it was given the pseudonym of "yuppie disease" in the popular press,
which added to the problem."
No cure for ME
Dr Enlander was due to give a talk,
organised by the Irish ME/CFS Association,
on the "Current treatment of ME/CFS"
at the Mount Herbert Hotel, Herbert Road, Dublin this Thursday, June 18.
At present there is no cure for ME, and no specific diagnostic test.
Diagnosis is made from recognising the main symptoms and ruling out of other illnesses.
However,
most patients have had positive exposure to one of a number of viruses,
such as Human Herpes virus 6 (HHV-6),
which can produce ill effect in the immune system.
"We are particularly interested in the immune system dysfunction.
That is what we are treating, to some good effect.
But there is no 100 per cent effective method of treatment,"
said Dr Enlander, ahead of the Dublin talk.
His clinic in Manhattan has devised a protocol
based on what is called the "Methylation Cycle",
which Dr Enlander believes is defective in this disease.
"The protocol that we use actually is
IMMUNOPROP and IMMUNOPlus capsules and
Hepapressin (generic Kutapressin) injection immune system modulators."
"We are also looking at hyperbaric oxygen treatment,
but this is at a very early stage," he added,
explaining that the thinking behind this was that
if you increase the oxygenation the patient will feel better.
A diagnostic test
His latest work involves a diagnostic test using hydrogen sulphide.
"Hydrogen sulphide is not the specific test for this disease, but it is an indicator of an abnormality."
Author of The CFS Handbook,
Dr Enlander has recently been appointed editor of a new medical journal, Fatigue,
which plans to start publishing early next year.
This, along with the formation of the new European Think Thank,
should help promote a greater understanding of the disease.
Last year's winner of the Nobel Prize in Medicine,
Prof Luc Montagnier of France, one of the discoverers of the HIV-virus,
is a supporter of the Think Tank,
but was unable to join the first meeting in Norway.
"Scientists have already uncovered a lot about ME,
but this information does not reach professional healthcare personnel,
and the disease is still not taken seriously," he commented.
"It is about time this changed."
Posted in Guests on 19 June 2009
Tags: research
http://www.imt.ie/opinion/2009/06/belfastborn_doctor_pushes_me_r.html
|
